White House Rejects Democrats' Preemptive Oversight Requests Citing Lack of Authority
The White House told high-level Democrats in Congress Wednesday that their letters demanding documents or information were not seeking legitimate oversight and instead intended to "harass and aggrandize."
Democrats have sent letters to Cabinet members and high-level White House officials, demanding that they preserve evidence ahead of planned oversight hearings or investigations once they take control of both chambers in January.
In a letter to ranking members of House and Senate committees, White House Counsel William O. Scharf said the Democrats did not currently hold power, and therefore Trump administration officials did not need to honor their requests.
Read More on Politics
"Some of these letters imply, without evidence, that thousands of United States government employees are conspiring to destroy documents in violation of the Federal Records Act," Scharf wrote in the letter shared with Newsweek. "One accuses law enforcement officials of engaging in 'unprecedented violence across the nation.' All drip with an animus or pettiness revealing that the purpose of these letters is not legitimate oversight but to harass and aggrandize."
In a letter sent to President Donald Trump's inner circle released earlier Wednesday, California Democratic Representative Robert Garcia called for recipients to preserve documents ahead of potential oversight hearings. Among those to receive the letter were Trump's two older sons, Vice President JD Vance, and Attorney General Todd Blanche.
Scharf said that because Democrats would not hold power until January, officials did not need to comply with the requests.
Newsweek reached out to Representatives Robert Garcia and Bennie Thompson, who are the ranking members of the House Oversight and House Homeland Security Committees, for comment via email Wednesday afternoon.
After their sweeping victories in the midterm elections, which teed the party up for majorities in both the House and the Senate, leading Democrats in Congress said that Trump administration officials should expect to be summoned for hearings on the Hill.
From immigration to the Justice Department to alleged conflicts of interest, the Democrats—some of whom will likely take leading roles on key committees—have said they need officials to preserve any and all evidence related to their planned investigations.
On Wednesday, Garcia's letters to Eric Trump, Donald Trump Jr., and the president's son-in-law Jared Kushner related to alleged conflicts of interest and their business dealings.
The letters to former U.S. Ambassador to Greece Kimberly Guilfoyle, White House Chief of Staff Stephen Miller, former Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem, and former senior DHS adviser Corey Lewandowski related to separate allegations of corruption, misconduct, abuse of power, and financial conflicts.
Notices to Vance, Blanche, and former White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles were about their handling of the Epstein files.
In a separate letter following the election, Representative Bennie Thompson of Mississippi urged Secretary of Homeland Security Markwayne Mullin to preserve documents related to immigration enforcement, pending his likely promotion to chair of the House Homeland Security Committee.
...
In his letter Wednesday, addressed to ranking members on Senate and House committees, Scharf said the Executive Branch had a longstanding policy of working with "Congressional requests for information," but only after receiving a request that comes with a legitimate legislative process.
Scharf said those requests needed to come from legitimate committees and their chairs, and went on to quote from a 2017 Department of Justice opinion on Congressional oversight.
"'Individual members of Congress, including ranking minority members, do not have the authority to conduct oversight in theabsence of a specific delegation by a full house, committee, or subcommittee,'" Scharf quoted.
"Your demands do not reflect a request of the House, Senate, or a committee to which that body's oversight authority has been delegated," the counsel said, adding that while some of those within the current Congress could become committee chairs, their requests could not carry over into the new Congress in January.
A White House official told Newsweek that this had been the Biden administration's policy in 2022 as well.
Democrats have appeared determined that they will call Trump administration officials before them in the new year, and that they will be required to answer questions.
Scharf appeared open to that in his letter, saying that in the future, many of those who had written letters to administration officials would be able to issue oversight requests. He said that the administration was "committed to working with future Chairs" within the rules he had outlined.
"Our commitment in this respect, though, is of course colored and qualified by the 'pettiness' promised by one potential incoming Chair and numerous other similar statements, which we believe indicate that you and your colleagues may inappropriately seek to use oversight investigations to harass individuals with meritless claims," Scharf concluded.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Gray R. Thomas